There are a variety of different things that can cause people with sensitivities to experience eye irritation. Spending too much time in the sun, wearing contacts, and starting at a computer screen are just some of the things that can irritate a person’s eyes. In a world that can be tough on sensitive eyes, women must do what they can to prevent possible irritation. And one of the first things they can do is change their mascara to a more eye-friendly formula.

Finding a mascara that’s gentle enough to be used by women with sensitive eyes isn’t an easy prospect, however. Although there are dozens of brands that claim to be gentle on eyes, the truth is only a handful is suitable for people with eye sensitivities. That’s why we’ve selected the ten best mascaras for sensitive eyes, so consumers can choose one that works for them.

Our Top Picks for the Best Mascaras For Sensitive Eyes

#1 Toullgo 4-D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

People may begin using this product because it’s gentle on sensitive eyes, but they usually continue to use it because of its quality. This mascara isn’t just a hypoallergenic mascara, but it’s also capable of delivering the length and volume that people desire from a high-quality mascara. It goes on smoothly, never clumps, and always provides all-day lash support that will impress everyone around the wearer. Since it’s waterproof, once it’s applied it stays put until it’s removed. And once the day is done, this product is easy to remove. All of these are good reasons for anyone to recommend this high-quality product.

#2 Nature Lash Mineral Mascara For Sensitive Eyes

This dual-purpose product can be used as both a mascara and a liquid eyeliner that’s gentle on sensitive eyes. It’s also a product that’s made with organic and botanical ingredients that are not only vegan but are also free of many of the irritating chemicals found in supermarket mascaras. This product is free of lead, petroleum, dyes, mercury, non-GMO ingredients, and even gluten. It’s easy-to-apply and builds lashes that have more volume and depth to them. It’s for these reasons alone that this is one of the best sensitive formula mascaras currently available.

#3 Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara

This 2-in-1 product not only works as a mascara but it also has a primer in it as well. This combination allows the wearer to craft their lashes the way they see fit and to create added depth and definition to their lashes. This product is also easy on the wearer’s eyes, all thanks to it being free of the irritating chemicals that can be found in some other mascaras. This product is completely free of silicones, mineral oil, artificial fragrances, paraffin, or parabens, so consumers can use it with confidence knowing that it not only won’t irritate their eyes but is also a healthier makeup choice.

#4 Vivienne Sabo Classic French Mascara

The first thing anyone who tries this mascara will notice is that it goes on in just one coat and immediately makes the eyelashes look fuller and thicker. However, that’s not the only thing worth mentioning about this product. This mascara is also made with a hypoallergenic formula that’s easy on the wearer’s eyes. Another thing worth mentioning is that it’s a completely ethical product that never been tested on animals, and it will never be tested on animals. That allows not only people with sensitive eyes to feel good about using this product but makes anyone who wears it feel good about using it.

#5 Physician’s Formula Black Organic Mascara

Who needs to mess with fake eyelashes when this organic mascara provides a better solution? The answer to that question is no one. This product is capable of delivering the big, beautiful lashes women expect, and it does without any of the harsh chemicals that can cause eye irritation. This mascara is free of parabens, SLS, and other ingredients that are not only irritating to the eyes but also potentially harmful as well. It’s hypoallergic and fragrance-free as well and is made with ingredients sourced from organic farms. All of which makes it hypoallergenic and safe for just about anyone to use.

#6 Naturally Rooted Premium Organic Mascara

People who don’t believe that a product can be used to create beautiful lashes and do it without containing harmful toxins have never tried this organic mascara. This product is capable of creating big, bold lashes, and it does it without harmful chemicals. This product is instead made with sunflower and chamomile oil, two ingredients that help to condition lashes as they provide volume. Since it’s made without gluten, dyes, or parabens, consumers also don’t have to worry about it irritating their sensitive eyes either. That makes a great product for anyone who wants beautiful lashes.

#7 W3LL People Expressionist Black Mascara

Anyone who thinks that this product is only on this list because it’s gentle for sensitive eyes better think again. Sure, it is a product that’s designed to be gentler on a woman’s eyes, so they avoid eye irritation, but it also has a lot more going for it. It’s also a product that’s cruelty-free, fiber-free and clump-free, too. It’s made without petroleum, gluten, aluminum, coal tar or the other irritating chemicals found in drugstore mascaras. And even though it doesn’t have all of those harmful chemical agents in it, it’s still capable of giving the wearer bold, fluffy lashes that will capture the attention of those around them.

#8 Cover Girl Professional Clear Mascara

Although not everyone understands the value of clear mascara, it’s just starting to become more popular. That’s because a clear mascara can do what black mascaras can’t, and that’s creating a light eyelash that looks completely natural. Another thing that’s great about a clear formula, is that it’s also extremely well suited to people with eye sensitivities. That’s because it doesn’t have the dyes that other types of beauty products have in them. And since this product has been fully vetted by ophthalmologists, the consumer can rest assured that it’s not going to irritate their eyes as other products will.

#9 Almay Thickening Waterproof Mascara

With just one coat, this mascara can double the thickness of the user’s lashes and do it without clumping. It’s also a product that won’t flake or smudge while being applied and is designed to be completely waterproof. And since it is infused with aloe and B-vitamins, it not only brings luxuriousness to the wearer’s lashes but also conditions them, too. Although all those things are great, the most important thing to mention about this product, however, is that it’s completely hypoallergenic. It won’t cause sensitivity issues to people wearing contact lenses or for people with sensitive eyes, and it has been fully ophthalmologist tested for safety.

#10 Lash Factory Black 3D Fiber Mascara

Just because a person has sensitive skin doesn’t mean that they can’t also have luscious lashes, especially if they’re using this product. This mascara by Lash Factory is designed to give the wearer 3-times the lash volume of comparable mascaras, and not just in length but also thickness as well. That allows the wearer to have the lashes of their dreams, and do it without experiencing eye discomfort or irritation. This product is a hypoallergenic formula that’s made without toxic ingredients such as SLS or parabens. And since it’s gentle, it’s not only suitable for people with eye sensitivities but is also suitable for contact lens wearers.

Mascara Tip For Sensitive Eyes

Finding the best mascara for sensitive eyes is only the beginning for people who have problems tolerating most of the commercial mascara products being produced. They then have to make sure that it is suitable for sensitive eyes and apply it in a way that ensures they get the maximum effect out of it with the smallest chance of developing some type of reaction to it. Towards that end, we’ve decided to write this guide on the subject of sensitive eyes. More specifically, this is a guide designed to give our readers tips for people with sensitive eyes that will help them get the most out of their mascara and do it without risking an adverse reaction. 

Step One: Choose The Right Mascara

Us giving our readers this tip might seem a little redundant—especially considering that we just went over some of the best sensitive eye mascaras—its importance warrants being mentioned here again. It’s extremely important to choose a mascara that says on the label that it’s allergy-tested, fragrance-free, and/or ophthalmologist tested. Always double check when buying a new mascara brand.

Step Two: Don’t Forget To Test

Just because mascara is designed to be allergy-free or for sensitive eyes doesn’t mean that you still couldn’t have a reaction to it. That’s why it’s important to always do a patch test before using it. To do a patch test, just add a little bit to the outer lashes and then wait a few hours. If there’s no reaction, you can then do a full application of the mascara. 

Step Three: Don’t Wear Nail Polish While Applying

Another great tip for avoiding eye irritation is to avoid wearing nail polish while you’re applying mascara. That’s because nail polish often contains Formaldehyde in it and that ingredient can cause eye irritation. If you don’t want to give up wearing polish, make sure to apply your mascara before applying your nail polish to help prevent eye irritation. 

Step Four: Be Careful Around The Lash Line

Another tip for preventing eye irritation is to make sure to not get too close to the lash line to avoid the mascara working its way down and irritating your eyelids. Start the mascara in the middle of the lashes and then gently sweep the product out to the outer edges of the lashes for the best results. 

Step Five: Be Careful With Mascara Removal

It’s also extremely important to make sure that you remove the mascara as carefully as you can at the end of the day. When it comes to sensitive eyes, the less rubbing that’s done the better. It’s also a good idea to remove mascara and eye makeup in separate steps. Soaking a cotton ball with an emulsifier-free makeup remove and gently patting the eyelashes can help to break the mascara’s adhesion to the lashes before removing it. This results in a few sweeps of the cotton ball and less irritation. 

Other Helpful Mascara Tips For Sensitive Eyes

The above five steps are the basics of using and removing mascara for people with sensitive eyes, but now it’s time to go over some additional tips that can also help avoid eye irritation. With that said, below are some additional tips for avoiding eye sensitivity that should be helpful in protecting our reader’s eyes. 

Avoid Waterproof Mascara

Although waterproof mascaras do certainly have their place, their place isn’t on the eyelashes of people with eye sensitivity. That’s because waterproof mascara adheres especially well to the eyelashes, so it can take a bit longer to remove. Because it takes longer to remove, it requires extra rubbing and as we’ve already said, extra rubbing equals extra eye irritation. 

Research Natural Mascaras

While some people would be quick to say that natural mascaras are less likely to cause eye irritation because they have “natural ingredients” that doesn’t mean that it won’t irritate the eyes. There are many natural compounds that can cause eye irritation, so it’s up to the consumer to do their due diligence and make sure their natural mascara isn’t going to irritate their eyes. 

Now, don’t misunderstand what we’re saying here. We’re not implying that all-natural ingredients can cause eye irritation. No, we’re not saying that at all. All we’re saying is that just because mascara is natural doesn’t mean it won’t cause eye irritation. 

Toss Mascara Out After Six Months

The last thing that we want to impress on our readers is that they should make sure that they toss their mascara out 6-months after first opening it. That’s because bacteria can begin to build up in the mascara at this time and the mascara might begin to break down. If the mascara isn’t open, you can toss it out after it has reached its expiration date, but if it’s opened, throw it out after 6-months—regardless of whether it’s past the expiration date or not.